An Argument for Collecting Half Dollars

When discussing U.S. coinage, the half dollar is often overlooked compared to the ever-popular quarter and the historically significant silver dollar. However, half dollars offer a unique combination of historical continuity, artistic design, and collector appeal that make them an exceptional choice for numismatists. Unlike silver dollars, which had multiple production gaps, half dollars have been minted nearly continuously since 1794, making them one of the most enduring denominations in U.S. history across a wide variety of turbulent moments.

Historical Continuity: The Half Dollar’s Legacy

One of the most compelling reasons to collect half dollars is their largely uninterrupted production. Since their inception in 1794, half dollars have been struck almost every year, with only a few exceptions. In contrast, the U.S. dollar coin has experienced several gaps in production which happened for reasons like;

1805–1835: No silver dollars were minted due to concerns over hoarding and bullion arbitrage.

1874–1877: Production of trade dollars continued, but standard silver dollars were not issued for circulation.

1905–1920: The morgan dollar ceased production after 1904, and the peace dollar did not begin until 1921.

1929–1933: No silver dollars were minted during the Great Depression.

1936–1970: Aside from commemoratives, the U.S. did not mint circulating silver dollars until the Eisenhower dollar in 1971.

1982–1998: No circulating dollar coins were issued until the Sacagawea dollar debuted in 2000.

While half dollars have a stronger record of consistency, there were a few exceptions to the run of this coin, which happened multiple times due to;

1798–1800: No half dollars were minted due to low demand and bullion supply issues.

1816: A fire at the Philadelphia mint prevented the production of half dollars.

1922, 1924–1926: No half dollars were struck due to a surplus of previous years' issues.

In addition, other U.S. denominations have also seen smaller interruptions when;

Two-cent pieces (1864–1873), three-cent pieces (1851–1889), and half cents (1793–1857) were discontinued entirely.

The half dime (1794–1873) was replaced by the nickel.

Nickels and cents continued production but saw composition changes (such as the 1943 steel cent and the 1942–1945 wartime nickel).

Quarters and dimes have been continuous since 1796 and 1796, respectively, though early issues had sporadic mintages.

This denomination has a lot more to it than many think.

Despite a few small gaps, the half dollar stands out as one of the few large silver denominations to maintain mostly consistent issuance, making it a prime candidate for collectors who appreciate an extensive U.S. historical record.

Size and Artistic Appeal

The half dollar also benefits from having a large surface area, second only to the dollar coin. This added space has allowed for some of the most striking designs in U.S. numismatics, which include commemoratives and standard coins including;

Flowing Hair and Draped Bust halves (1794–1807) – Early, intricate designs from the infancy of U.S. coinage.

Capped Bust (1807–1839) – A robust, classical style that reflects the early 19th century.

Seated Liberty (1839–1891) – A long-running and elegant depiction of Liberty.

Barber (1892–1915) – A distinctive portrait by Charles E. Barber.

Walking Liberty (1916–1947) – Often regarded as one of the most beautiful coin designs ever struck.

Franklin (1948–1963) – Featuring Benjamin Franklin, this series stood out with its Liberty Bell reverse.

Kennedy (1964–Present) – A tribute to President John F. Kennedy, with a design that has remained largely unchanged since 1964.

These designs, combined with their larger size, make half dollars an aesthetically pleasing and historically rich series to collect whatever one’s interests may be.

Collector Appeal and Market Affordability

Despite their significance, half dollars often receive less attention than quarters or silver dollars. Quarters have gained popularity due to modern series like the 50 State Quarters and America the Beautiful programs. Silver dollars, particularly morgan and peace dollars, are highly sought after for their size and silver content. However, half dollars offer a middle ground between affordability and numismatic prestige. Many circulated examples remain reasonably priced, while key dates and high-grade specimens present exciting challenges for collectors.

Additionally, varieties and errors—such as overdates, doubled dies, and re-punched mintmarks—provide further opportunities for specialized collecting.

Conclusion: The Overlooked Gem

For collectors seeking a blend of historical depth, artistic beauty, and accessibility, the U.S. half-dollar stands as an underrated treasure. Its largely uninterrupted mintage, large canvas for stunning designs of various topics, and affordability make it a series worthy of greater recognition. Whether pursuing a type set, a full-date run, or varieties, half dollars offer a rich collecting experience that deserves more appreciation in the numismatic community from now on.

Have an interesting numismatic topic you’d like to share with your fellow NOW members?

Send your article to evan.pretzer@protonmail.com today!!!

For more NOW Articles Written By Members, join N.O.W. today!